- 1 Costco No Longer Accepting American Express In 2016 After Striking Deal With Visa, Citigroup
- 2 Which Costco Membership is worth the money? + Costco Visa changes!!
- 3 Watch the TV segment online or click and watch below (then get all my other tips farther down in the post):
- 4 costco changing credit cards
- 5 Costco Changed Its Payment System: What Does this Mean for You?
- 6 Credit card two-step leaves Costco customers sidelined
Costco No Longer Accepting American Express In 2016 After Striking Deal With Visa, Citigroup
Customers at Costco. (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)
FOSTER CITY (CBS / AP) — If you’re shopping at Costco, you’ll need a new credit card to pay for those family-sized packs of chicken breasts or toilet paper.
After only accepting American Express the last 16 years, the retailer is switching to Foster City-based card giant Visa and will use Citigroup as its exclusive provider of co-branded credit cards.
Costco is a large and influential chain. It is the world’s second-largest retailer by revenue, and has 671 locations around the world, including 474 in the U.S. and Puerto Rico. For an annual fee of $55 to $110, shoppers get access to groceries in bulk sizes, as well as appliances, jewelry, home goods and other products.
The switch from AmEx to Visa could mean changes for some of those customers. Here are the things you need to know:
Costco will only accept Visa credit cards at its stores starting April 1, 2016. Customers will also be able to use Visa and MasterCard debit cards, or pay in cash. American Express credit cards will no longer be accepted on that date. That’s a hit to AmEx. Last year, Costco accounted for 8 percent of American Express billed business, 10 percent of its cards in force and 20 percent of its worldwide loans.
Citigroup is also expected to take over the existing American Express Costco credit cards.
WILL I HAVE TO REAPPLY FOR A COSTCO CREDIT CARD?
Costco hasn’t said yet whether people will have to reapply for its rewards credit card. Citigroup says it plans to make the transition from AmEx to the Citi’s Visa card as “seamless” as possible.
Costco card holders probably won’t need to reapply, industry experts say. However, a small number of Costco card holders won’t be approved for a Citi card. American Express and Citi have different credit standards and a person who may have qualified under AmEx may not be approved under Citi. The people affected are likely to be small, however, since American Express’ qualifications are some of the highest in the industry.
When its agreement came up for renewal, AmEx and Costco were unable to reach a deal that both sides liked.
WHY ANNOUNCE THIS A YEAR AHEAD?
After the announcement last month that Costco was ending its relationship with American Express, “we wanted to reassure everyone that we had another deal in the works,” says David Sherwood, director of finance and investor relations at Costco.
WILL THE CITI CARD OFFER SIMILAR REWARDS AS AMEX?
That is still to be determined, but industry experts say it is likely. As with the American Express card, the new Citi card will have no annual fee, Costco says. And like with AmEx, the new card will serve as a membership card.
With the Amex card, Costco customers get 3 percent cashback on fuel purchases, 2 percent back on restaurants and eligible travel and 1 percent cashback on all other purchases. The cashback comes in the form of a check issued every February. Customers can use the check for goods at a Costco checkout line, or redeem it at the customer service desk for actual cash.
The cashback program on the American Express card was good for Costco because customers would use their checks to buy more Costco goods. Citi also has a long history of issuing credit cards with cashback programs.
“It makes sense from Costco’s perspective to have the cashback program,” says Ken Paterson with Mercator Advisory Group, a banking industry consulting firm.
WHAT ABOUT THE CARD I HAVE NOW?
Any cashback rewards earned on the Costco American Express card will be valid, Costco says. Cardholders have until August 31, 2016 to redeem the rewards that are issued in February 2016.
© Copyright 2015 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Which Costco Membership is worth the money? + Costco Visa changes!!
It's no secret that I love Costco, and have become somewhat of a Costco pro over the years (if you haven't noticed by my Costco page!). They have great prices on quality items and it can really save your family a lot of money…IF you do it right! I recently did a TV segment for Studio 5 all about Costco, so I thought I'd share the video PLUS my inside scoop on how to save money at Costco, what to buy and what to avoid, what membership is worth the money, and inside details about the new Costco + Visa relationship!
Watch the TV segment online or click and watch below (then get all my other tips farther down in the post):
So there you have it! Here's a breakdown of tips, tricks, and info to help even more:
Did you know that depending on your membership, you can get cash back for shopping at Costco? That's right folks, real-deal-moola. With the Executive Membership you get 2% cash back on your purchases, and that comes back to you in the form of a rebate check. You can use the rebate you get right at Costco or, even better, you can go to the customer service desk and redeem that for cold, hard CASH! For a family like mine who only shops at Walmart and Costco, this is a huge benefit that really pays off.
Let's start with the basics.
The Executive Membership will cost you $110, whereas the Standard Membership is $55 range. That's quite a price difference, I know. But the main difference is that the Executive Membership is what grants you the ability to get that glorious cash-back rebate (mentioned above). Again, for a family who shops at Costco regularly (like we do) this is worth the money because the cash back earned exceeds the cost of the membership.
Not sure if you should jump for the Executive Membership?
Have no fear. You actually have nothing to lose by upgrading to the Executive Membership! At the end of the year if you haven't earned at least the money you spent on the Executive Membership, they will refund you the difference between the Executive and Standard memberships (about $60), and downgrade you to the Standard Membership retroactively. Just another reason I love me some Costco…
The rumors are true! Amex and Costco are divorcing for good. For better or for worse, as of June 19th, 2016 Costco will no longer accept American Express. I know change is hard, and I really really love my Amex (they have the BEST customer service, in my opinion.) But in this case, change can be a good thing!
After June 19th, you can use ANY Visa card at Costco, not just the Costco branded one. Since many of us have Visa cards in our wallet already, this is fabulous news. Even better news? In the kingdom of retail, Costco is KING; and with that kind of power they have the ability to pull off some incredible deals. This new Visa + Costco relationship is no exception. Costco has negotiated even better kickbacks and perks than they had with Amex! Including:
- 4% on Gas (Amex was only 3%)
- 3% on Travel & Restaurants (Amex was 2%)
- 2% on ANYTHING at Costco (Amex was 1%)
- 1% on anything else, ANYWHERE
That's a tough question. I'm not one to endorse running out and applying for credit cards, because it dings your credit when you do, and credit cards aren't for the faint of heart. However, I know for us, having the Costco Amex was a huge money-saver for our family. We haven't decided fully yet, but we will most likely get the Costco Visa card. Our credit scores are in the high 800's so we don't feel like it's a huge risk for our family. And since Costco is the only place we shop for all of our businesses AND one of 2 places we shop at for our own family, the cash back through Costco and Visa would really add up. Again, we haven't decided yet for sure. In the meantime we will just use our existing Visa cards until we decide. Just make an educated decision about what's best for your family!
If you have the Costco Amex, you could certainly continue to use it for purchases outside of Costco if you feel the perks outweigh the perks of other cards you have. Whatever you do, just don't cancel the card. That's actually a red flag for creditors. It's better to have a credit card account open and unused, than it is to cancel one.
A common misconception is that everything at Costco is a fantastic deal. While yes, they do have fantastic deals, not everything will save you money. Head to THIS POST to get my big list of what to buy and what to avoid at Costco, and see THIS PAGE for lots more tips as well.
Quick Costco tip: If you see an asterisk (you know, one of these *) on a price tag at Costco, take note! It means they will NOT be restocking that item and when it's gone, it's gone. If the price tag ends ends in .97, that product's price has been marked down. If you find a golden goose with BOTH an asterisk and a price ending in .97, might just be a killer deal you should take advantage of!
This is one of my best-kept secrets. If you buy something at Costco and you see it go on sale within the next 30 days, you can go to the customer service desk and they will refund you the difference! Rumor has it some stores require you to have your receipt, so hold onto those just in case. I've never had that issue, they have always been able to look up my purchases in their computer. Either way, that's pretty dang sweet and something you should know for sure!
costco changing credit cards
Enter up to 25 symbols separated by commas or spaces in the text box below. These symbols will be available during your session for use on applicable pages.
Select the background color of your choice:
Select a default target page for your quote search:
You have selected to change your default setting for the Quote Search. This will now be your default target page; unless you change your configuration again, or you delete your cookies. Are you sure you want to change your settings?
Costco Changed Its Payment System: What Does this Mean for You?
US retailer giant Costco recently made a massive change to its payment system. Since 1999, Costco only accepted American Express credit cards. But just recently, the company made a major policy change and now only accepts Visa credit cards. This transition is huge for the millions of Americans who shop at Costco and it is being debated by shoppers and analysts alike. But why did Costco make this change, what are the impacts and what does it mean for you?
American Express was once the only card accepted at Costco. The decision to give the ax to American Express will likely have a major impact on the company. The two companies previously had a deal to brand an American Express credit card to be used at Costcos across the nation. Close to 10 percent of all American Express cards were for use at Costco, while 20 percent of American Express’ loan portfolio came from these cards. The reason Costco dropped this 16-year relationship is because American Express could not meet Costco’s demands. Due to recent legislation from the government, all financial companies are now forced to meet certain stress test requirements in case of a financial crisis. Should a particular company have too many nonperforming loans, some of those loans must be written off to reduce system risk and bankruptcy.
American Express happens to be one company that has a lower than average number of underperforming or nonperforming loans. The company is known for its risk management skills. Costco demanded that the credit card company reduce transaction fees while also boosting rewards on spending. This would likely increase overall spending on American Express cards, which would subsequently lead to more risk. This is an option that American Express is unlikely to take, especially considering the new regulations from the government forcing financial companies to reduce the percentage of risky loans that exist in their portfolio.
While the media and the financial world continue its debate, American Express will likely continue to push forward. It is unlikely the case that the company will go bankrupt or even post significant losses. If anything, American Express has set a precedent. Not only did a credit card company stand up to a major retail giant, but also the company showed an enormous amount of fiscal responsibility. Rather than taking Costco’s offer – which would surely lower profit, but not as much as ending the relationship – the company instead chose to take the less risky path and decided to continue its current business policy of low risk ventures.
It may seem unlikely, but the split between Costco and American Express may impact you more than you think. First, because Costco now accepts only Visa cards, it’s likely the case that more of your cards will be eligible for purchases at Costco. The Visa payment system is used by more cards than any other in the world by far. It makes up more than 50 percent of all credit card transactions globally. Statistically speaking, you probably have at least one Visa based credit card. Even if you don’t currently have a Visa card, acquiring one will be a simple matter because it is offered by so many different companies. Additionally, Costco switched from American Express specifically because American Express would not lower transaction fees and increase rewards. Instead, the retailer went a different route, and now shopping at Costco may be slightly cheaper and potentially could earn you more rewards points.
Posted on July 14, 2016 by Ryan in Credit Cards
Credit card two-step leaves Costco customers sidelined
Roseanne Skopp and Milissa Martinez have credit cards that they not only can no longer use, but with balances that they still have to pay – and that are still accruing interest.
The source of their agony? Costco’s recent breakup with American Express and its new partner, Citibank.
Both Skopp and Martinez requested help from our advocacy team in navigating the change and adjusting their accounts.
In February 2016, American Express announced that it was parting ways with Costco Wholesale. Costco American Express cardholders would have their cards invalidated and replaced by Citibank accounts.
Costco’s change in credit card partners means that the American Express Costco Co-Brand Card is not accepted at Costco, and that Costco does not accept any other American Express cards for payment of purchases.
Skopp claims that she did not authorize Costco to issue her a Citibank card, let alone issue charges to her on it, and is looking for legal assistance with her case, which we as consumer advocates can’t and don’t provide. Our advocates have advised her to contact an attorney to pursue legal action against Costco and Citibank. She’s hoping we can assist her anyway.
Martinez, on the other hand, would be only too happy to use a Citibank card issued by Costco. She was “very happy” with her Costco Amex card until the partnership ended. Amex invalidated Martinez’s card but will not transfer the $5,000 balance of her account to Citibank because of an issue with her address:
I am having an extreme problem with American Express. They deactivated my Amex/Costco card stating there was an issue with my address. I had spoken to them multiple times before about the same issue and was always told that there was no issue.
Our home burned down; I lost everything exactly one year ago this week.
I advised Amex of this. I said I’d give them a permanent address when I had one but for now [the address on the account] is the address. It is on my and my son’s California IDs and on file with the state. After a long, drawn-out week with Amex, I was told today:
- not only will they not reactivate my card and account
- I have to keep paying the card [balance] and [it will keep] accruing interest.
- They will not transfer my balance to Citibank as promised and I have the cards for already.
- They will not transfer my account to another Amex card.
- I cannot use the Amex card anymore but still must pay it.
To summarize: Amex won’t transfer Martinez’s balance to Citibank or allow her to keep using its card, but it’s charging interest on the remaining balance on its now-useless card. And this is after a tragedy in which she lost everything.
Not only that, Amex sent her account to collections — even though she’s always paid it in full on time. She’s spoken many times to Amex personnel, including supervisors, who have been unhelpful at best.
We may not be able to do much for Skopp, but Martinez’s case cries out for help. She wants her Amex account taken out of collections, reactivated and transferred to Citibank — without the accrued interest. Our advocates have contacted American Express on her behalf.
As a takeaway, we advise all Costco members to be completely aware of the terms of Costco’s change from Amex to Citibank, including the deactivation of Costco American Express cards and transfers of balances, as well as interest charges, to Costco Citibank cards. Company contact information for Costco, American Express, and Citibank can be found on our website.
Also, credit card customers who need help and haven’t received it might file complaints with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
Above all, don’t be taken by surprise.
Jennifer is the founder of KeenReader, an Internet-based freelance editing operation, as well as a certified public accountant. She is Manager-at-Large and Senior Writer for Elliott.org.
I fully understand her frustration with not being able to use the Amex any longer, etc but what I don’t understand is why she believes she should not pay interest on unpaid balance on Amex even if the card is no longer useable.
That debt doesn’t vanish because the card is invalid.
Maybe I am misunderstanding something here because there is another statement in which it is said she always pays off her Amex balance in full, on time – which would lead me to believe, she never would even have a balance due now, let alone interest.
And, no, the debacle of them switching cards with COSTCO was not handled well, but when do financial institutions ever handle this sort of thing well for consumers?
I guess I must be missing something here. Ms. Martinez would be happy to pay off her old AMEX balance, but only if they transfer the balance to the new Costco card [which she cannot presently get transferred because of a technical or legal issue]. Why cant she just pay it off with AMEX while she is waiting on the address issues with the new COSTCO card to be cleared away? I dont see where she is claiming she did not spend that money at COSTCO via AMEX, All I see is someone looking for any excuse to not have to take personal responsibility for her debts. I am sorry that she had a fire and such, but if she isnt paying off her balance with AMEX, why does she think she shouldn’t be paying interest?
While it sucks to not be able to use a card anymore, especially after a tragic event, unless charges were made that weren’t theirs, why would they be seeking legal advice or any other assistance with essentially being let off the hook for paying for things THEY BOUGHT? The interest part I’m confused about. Was the original card “Interest Free for X months” or something and with the invalidation of that card, that changed? Unless that’s the case, they owe the balance AND the interest. I’ve always found AmEx personnel to be very helpful, so I wonder if there’s “more to the story” here…
Martinez’s issues are with the card company, not Costco. Whatever the address and transfer issues are they’re not Costco’s doing. And naturally she’s still being charged interest and needs to pay the balance off. She’d need to pay it if it was transferred over to another card, too.
Skopp’s complaint I don’t fully understand. She says Costco never got permission to issue charges to the new card but what new charges were made after the transfer? Does Costco have some sort of program where she was paying auto-fees or something that got rolled over to the new card?
I thought the transition between the two cards went better than expected personally. Since there wasn’t any detail on Skopp’s issue (you could opt out of the new card if you wanted and you were told in writing that your member fees would be charged to it just like the AMEX), I really can’t comment there.
I really don’t understand Martinez’s issue. She ran up a balance. It will accrue interest until its paid off regardless of the card its on. The balance just doesn’t go away. If she really wants to transfer the balance, I get 5 offers a week to do just. I don’t see an issue here.
> not only will they not reactivate my card and account
Amex’s agreement with Citi requires them to close all of the Costco accounts.
> I have to keep paying the card [balance] and [it will keep] accruing interest.
Yes, that’s generally how credit cards work. Once you pay off the balance it will stop accruing interest.
> They will not transfer my balance to Citibank as promised and I have the cards for already.
This is the consumer’s only valid point, but it seems to stem from some sort of technical issue that’s not well explained.
> They will not transfer my account to another Amex card.
Amex’s agreement with Citi prevents them from transferring Costco accounts to new Amex accounts.
> I cannot use the Amex card anymore but still must pay it.
Again, that’s how closed credit card accounts work.
Regarding Skopp’s issue, I personally despise Citibank and was very happy to call up and cancel the account
as soon as I received the card. The rep was very friendly and efficient,
surprisingly the best interaction I’ve ever had with them.
Plenty of consumers like myself were not happy to be issued Citi cards, but the solution was straightforward and no more than a minor hassle. I dealt with it and have moved on. She should, too.
I really like this explanation..
I am going to assume the technical issue is that of the address. Assuming she is a new customer of Citibank, there might be some fraud prevention mechanisms in place. Citibank may want a permanent address on file.and one can advise Amex all you want, Citi sees things differently.
There is also the slight possibility that she no longer qualifies for the credit card. I thought that Costco membership would be sufficient, but is it possible that she is too in debt to open a new account. I can only imagine what a house burning down does do savings.
There was plenty of notice given by Costco about the change. They dumped AX and Sam’s Club picked them right up. 5-6 months notice allowed me to make any and all arrangements necessary. Even though they were AX cards, they were handled somewhat differently than AX Blue, Gold, Black, Etc cards. and to get the exact “legal” difference, your team would need to contact AX directly. They are club cards with many of the same privileges of the normal card, but far less credit for those getting them. My old Discover card from Sams was not handled by Discover, but by Synchrony Bank, so calling 1-800- DISCOVER was useless. I am assuming, maybe incorrectly, that this was the same case for Costco.
I do not understand why a collection agency is involved. If a person is making regular payments, credit card companies love the extra money. Something is a bit amiss.
My balance was seamlessly moved from AX to City bank.
Wait…yes of course you have to pay off your credit card balance even if the account is closed. It sounds like this person doesn’t realize you can have two credit cards at the same time.
Years ago I got over my head in credit and went to credit counseling. They negotiated set monthly payment amounts, including for Amex. Amex is the only one that despite making the payments as agreed, wrote off my balance, sent it to collections, and put it on my credit reports. They also made a number of collection phone calls, dispute agreeing to payments, that today would be illegal (like threatening to have me arrested). All of the other creditors, reported as paid as agreed as long as I did not miss a payment. So the Amex doing what they did to Milissa Martinez does not surprise me.
Did the COSTCO Citi card have an interest free balance transfer window? This might be why she is upset about paying interest on the closed AmEx card because they will not transfer the balance. I don’t have any COSTCO accounts so I have not seen the new card offer from Citi, but I am willing to bet that it specifically states a transfer from AmEx COSTCO to the Citi card is exempt from the no interest period. So she would still have paid.
It sounds like her house may have been lost in one of the wildfires in California and the state/county is not going to allow her to rebuild on that property meaning the address is no longer valid. Her mail is probably being delivered to a temporary address. I can’t imagine the confusion that would cause.
I had a similar issue with AmEx many many years ago where I had paid off my balance and closed my account after struggling to pay them for several months. While I was never sent to collections, they did report me to the credit bureaus repeatedly even after I paid them off. Nearly cost me my job. The issue eventually went away when I applied for and received a new AmEx card.
Annual membership fee for COSTCO is one that gets auto billed. But if you don’t pay it, you can’t shop there.
I got calls for someone I didn’t know when I first got a new phone number a few years ago, who apparently ran up a lot of bills and never paid them. Most stopped calling relatively quickly, once or twice and they’d remove the number. The two that didn’t? Comcast and AmEx. The Comcast calls were automated and it took 20+ minutes to get a person because they just wanted you to pay. AmEx, on the other hand, literally screamed at me that I was lying and that my name was Nicole (it isn’t) and I’d better pay the balance. It was very bizarre, I didn’t think collection reps did that anymore. It took a good 2 or 3 months to get them to stop calling.
I suspect this has to do with the fact that a “valid” mailing address must be on file, under the patriot act. I dealt with a customer with a similar issue. There’s nothing an advocate, or anyone short of a member of Congress can do. AmEx and Citi would be violating compliance laws if they allowed this OP to have an invalid address on her account. The workaround is extremely simple. The bank must only keep a valid address on file, it can be mailed anywhere (like for customers that have a UPS store box or a PO Box because their true address is a RR that doesn’t receive delivery).
Someone realized that they were allowing the OP to have an address on file that violated federal compliance laws. It doesn’t matter the circumstances, it’s a BIG DEAL. Why someone didn’t explain this to her is beyond me, I would guess they have and she doesn’t like it. She has to have a valid residential and mailing address. If it isn’t valid, it violates the patriot act for the bank to have it on file.
Clearly the leopard has not changed their spots in the 23 years since I had Amex issues.
It’s not a fraud issue. It’s a compliance issue. It’s against federal law for an account to have an invalid address. It’s also against the law for the bank not to have the address of the customer. That’s the problem. There’s nothing an advocate can do. Compliance trumps everyone, it’s literally a matter of federal law with significant civil penalties.
Isn’t where she is receiving mail a valid address? Unless she is using a PO Box (and refusing to provide a physical location) or is going back to the burned residence to collect mail, what’s the issue?
“she always pays off her Amex balance in full, on time” – I think this is referring to the MINIMUM payment to keep the account out of collections, not the actual balance.
Not necessarily. I remember this issue, back when I worked in compliance, would rear it’s head sometimes. The post office may simply be holding the mail (similar to if you go on vacation). Someone else made the point that the home may have been destroyed in a wildfire and she won’t be allowed to rebuild there. This seems the most likely scenario, but there are other odd scenarios that concern zoning and there’s no need to get into.
The point is, all that matters is what the federal government says under the patriot act specifically, and any other regulations that may apply. Or, more correctly, how the feds have interpreted those rules. If a house can’t be built there, and it’s an individual, consumer account (it could be zoned for only business and a business account, that doesn’t apply here, if we’re getting into semantics), under interpretation of the patriot act, it’s illegal to use the address. It doesn’t matter if mail is addressed there, it frankly doesn’t matter if the county clerk or even the governor of CA personally signs and has notarized a letter stating she could use it as her address. Under federal law, the bank isn’t complying. Again, compliance trumps everyone. They will not allow it.
Citi was not offering any special interest rates on balance transfers — the interest rate was the same as for purchases– they were offering 0 percent interest on NEW purchases (ie done with their card) for the first 7 months.
This does not make sense — “even though she’s always paid it in full on time”. If it paid in full then there is no balance due to send to collections. And how can there be $5,000 balance if paid in full?
As for the person who did not want the AmexCostco card transferred to Citibank — why not cancel the card before the transfer? There were mass mailings and info on the AmEx website.
Isn’t where she is receiving mail a valid address?
It wouldn’t have to be. I don’t know what rules financial institutions need to follow but you can very easily get mail and have an address not fully verified or validated by the post office. We do a lot of direct mail and use postal verification and have seen lots of cases where customers who we successfully billed (because we take whatever address they give us for that) will fall out of DM campaigns where we do use verification coding.
I wondered the same thing. If you pay it every month, the balance is going to be $0. So I assume she just didn’t pay the final month? But you’d have to not pay for a couple months to go to collections. Very confusing.
I have a suspicion both these complaints come from the core issue of not paying attention to what was being communicated. This reminds me a lot of the case from a few days ago where the guy admitted to getting an email with flight change information included but he didn’t bother to read it until after he’d missed his flight. Some people could be told something 10 different times in 10 different ways yet would remain oblivious.
With a balance of 5000 that must have been an active month. I wonder if the payments were just the minimum payments to keep account current? But if one is paying them then a card would not go to collections.
Amex cannot reactivate a Costco branded card as their own; I believe a person has to reapply for a normal ie non co branded card.
For the person that objected to being given a citi card– from consumerist web page
“The Truth In Lending Act addresses the issue of credit card account transfers between two different credit issuers. Under the Act and Regulation Z, a card issuer is barred from issuing a card that a consumer has not applied for — except in very specific situations, including those times when a credit issuer has purchased accounts from another issuer.
In this case, the new owner can issue an updated card as long as the
use of the old card is cut off and the new cards can be issued in a
However, a rep for Costco tells Consumerist that current cardholders can
contact American Express to opt-out of getting a new Citi Visa account.
But this comes with the caveat that, even if you tell AmEx you’re
opting out, Costco might still send you a new card”
You’ve hit the nail on the head here. I just can’t believe no one has explained to the address lady it’s a compliance issue. It isn’t a secret. Nowhere I’ve ever worked has it been an issue to explain something like having an invalid address violates federal law. It’s not a security issue. I think she just doesn’t like it.
My understanding is that when they switched over, AmEx transferred the balances to Citi to be applied to the new cards. Therefore she has the old balance on the new card. This would make sense say someone has a $1000 line on their AmEx and now Amex doesn’t serve Costco any longer, the account transfers to Citi also with $1000. Customers would effectively have a double credit line, so Citi pays off AmEx and applies the charges to the new accounts.
Which is not in full.
So if she got a PO box temporarily where she’s actually living, the whole issue would be solved as I understand it. Right?
Personally, I like the Costco Visa. It pays more cash back on many purchases (including gas and travel) than the old Amex. Also, Visa cards are accepted nearly everywhere; Amex cards not so much–try using one overseas and you’ll find they mostly don’t accept them outside of big hotels and major airlines.
Exactly! I fail to see the problem. Her old card and account are no longer valid for new purchases. Why does she think she’s not responsible for the debt? As far as the address goes, where do the bills go? Irrelevant anyway–she owes the money regardless of the address problem and the house fire.
If Skopp did not authorize Citibank to issue her a new credit card, how did it happen? I don’t see that COSTCO can just tell Citibank to issue her a card. Someone had to order the card. How was COSTCO putting charges on the card she never asked for? Was she using it in the store for purchases? Something just does not smell right here.
The Patriot Act [and most likely the banks own internal compliance even if the Patriot Act didn’t] requires a physical address even though you may receive mail at a post office box. Even forgetting the Patriot Act, from the banks own perspective, how would they serve legal papers for example if they had no physical address for a borrower or credit card holder?
I thought the transition from Amex to Citi Visa went totally smoothly (except for a short-lived minor glitch when I couldn’t download a .pdf of my statement from Citi). I don’t miss Amex at all, and the rewards with Citi (4% back on gas, for example) are better than they were with Amex. In addition, I like being able to use another Visa card at Costco if I choose to.
I wonder what some people forced to take Citi card would say had they known who owns significant part of the Citi Bank and who is on its board of directors.
Some people may not like sending money to Saudi Arabia like that.
Wherever she’s living has to be a valid physical address at least temporarily unless she’s sleeping on the street, right?
I don’t think so. My father’s house burned down after I had long since moved out. Since the physical address the house was at was still their property, the post office held the mail for them until they were living in a rental that had a mailbox.
Sounds good in theory, and if you are registering an out of state corporation or LLC to do business someplace, you have to do that, but unfortunately this will not satisfy the requirements of the Patriot Act, nor the requirements of most [if not all] financial institutions compliance and legal departments.
I see your point; however, i also know that my home address is not a valid address. I have lived there for 4 years, and have had some issues when it comes to address validation; however, a letter from the post office usually corrects the issue. The main issue I have is that we do not have route delivery where I live, so the USPS offers what is called a class E PO Box. I have a physical address for 911 purposes; however anyone using address validation will get that address as invalid as the USPS does not deliver there. Instead, they offer me a free PO Box since I am not eligible for route delivery.
In the 1st case, she needs to call Citi and cancel the card. In the 2nd, I don’t see how it’s related to Costco at all. It sounds like Amex closed her account for whatever reason. You don’t have your account closed for a fire. However she says the issue has been ongoing but she is too vague about the problem. Amex sent her to collections so I guarantee it would love to have dumped her on Citi. Amex closes accounts for many reasons. They sometimes freeze them and provide an opportunity to submit info, sometimes they don’t. There is nothing stopping her from applying for the Citi Costco card. Just like you can’t force Amex to extend credit to someone against its will, you can’t force Citi, either. If she isn’t paying the bill, of course they are going to send her to collections. They don’t send you when they close the account so long as you continue to meet the obligation.
Amex did her a favor. If she can’t manage the monthly payments as is, then the last thing she needs is more credit extended so that her debt is larger to pay each month. She should cut up all her cards and work out a plan to settle/payoff the existing debt. Leaning on Costo/Citi to extend credit to someone who is having difficulty managing makes the problem so much worse and could cause her further loss. The interest will be predatory and in 6 months her situation will be so much worse.
Because she didn’t. She stopped paying it or fell behind. Amex doesn’t close your account bc you have a fire and a temp change of address. But they may if you become homeless bc if you can’t pay such an essential thing then the last thing you need is more credit to buy huge boxes of stuff at Costco. I feel terrible for her but the solution she wants is just a bandaid. There is nothing Amex has done to prevent her from applying for the Costo citi card.
Yes, but it doesn’t seem like she has a PO box, otherwise she would have mentioned it. That’s all I’m saying.
I said, “No,” because of my experience. Costco did not send me my replacement card until a week and a half ago. That was after many phone calls telling them they forgot about me somehow. And I do pay off the entire balance on my cards every month. I’m actually happy the card was replaced. The only reason I used an AMEX card was because Costco required it. Some years ago, they made a mistake on my account. They added charges and harassed me about the balance until I proved it was their mistake. That was in the days of written checks for payment and long waits to get copies of payments.
Allianz Travel Insurance — The Allianz Travel Insurance company has built its reputation on partnering with agents all around the world to provide comprehensive travel insurance for their clients. Contact Allianz Travel Insurance for a comprehensive list of coverage.
Chubb -- Chubb is the world's largest publicly traded property and casualty insurance company, and recognized as the premier provider of insurance for successful individuals and families in the U.S. and selected international markets, offering coverage for high-value automobile, homeowners, recreational marine/aviation, valuables and umbrella liability coverage. As an underwriting company, Chubb assesses, assumes and manages risk with insight and discipline, and combines the precision of craftsmanship with decades of experience to conceive, craft and deliver the best insurance coverage and services to individuals, families and business of all size.
Enterprise — A family-owned, world-class portfolio of brands. A global network that spans across more than 85 countries. Some 97,000 dedicated team members sharing common values. And more than 1.9 million vehicles taking our customers wherever they need to go.
Fareportal — Fareportal’s portfolio of brands, which include CheapOair and OneTravel, are dedicated to helping customers enjoy their trip. Whether you want to call, click, or use one of our travel apps, one thing is clear: We make it easy to take it easy.
Insuremyrentalcar.com – An independent provider of low cost CDW/LDW insurance for use with rental cars. Up to $100,000 cover with no deductible. Policies available on a per day, per trip or per year basis. Also works with overseas rentals. Try Insuremyrentalcar.com now.
North America’s leading provider of legal safeguards and protection against identity theft solutions for individuals, families and small businesses. They’ve built a community of 1.65 million members and growing. Their mobile app allows you to connect to your law firm from the palm of your hand. LegalShield provides affordable access to lawyers in all 50 states, empowering citizens and providing peace of mind.
Support this site. If you’ve benefitted from the stories, posts or executive contacts on this site, please consider supporting us. You can become an Elliott underwriter by making a donation through PayPal now. The funds will help pay for web hosting, IT services and the expenses for publishing this incredibly useful consumer advocacy site.
Get behind the advocacy in other ways. It’s easy! Whitelist your ad blocker for our site and visit our advertisers. Or use these affiliate links to go shopping on Amazon, sign up for a new Google Fi account or get a Dropbox subscription.
We’ll get a small referral fee for each item you purchase. (Note: We don’t endorse or promote any products offered online.)
MedjetAssist — MedjetAssist is the premier global and domestic air-medical transport membership program for travelers. If you become hospitalized more than 150 miles from home, and you are a member of MedjetAssist, we will get you from that unfamiliar hospital all the way home to the hospital you trust. All you pay for this bedside-to-bedside is your membership fee. Become a Medjet member today and take advantage of discounted rates available for Elliott.org readers. We’re not insurance, we’re better: MedjetAssist.
Travel Insurance – Squaremouth.com helps travelers easily and instantly compare all the major travel insurance plans. To ensure customer satisfaction, only companies that meet squaremouth.com’s strict requirements make it into the system. You can save over 70 percent on your next policy at Squaremouth.
Travel Leaders Group - Travel Leaders Network assists millions of leisure and business travelers, annually, and is the largest seller of luxury travel, cruises, river cruises and tours in the travel agency industry. It is also the largest travel agent organization selling corporate travel. Led by flagship Travel Leaders-branded travel agencies, the network includes nearly 7,000 Associates and Member travel agencies locations in the United States and Canada and represents more than $21 billion in annual sales volume.